Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Harigovind S's avatar

One point I would like to add is that adjustment is coming from RAs too, who now understand that their speciality is not in being an extra pair of hands but as an extra, perhaps less well developed, brain. As someone who has been RAing for a few years now I have seen my own willingness to critically examine and provide feedback on what I used to earlier consider the authors’ job. This includes matters of identification, motivation, novelty of claims, and robustness. The question, as you rightly point out, is whether I would have been able to do so without the training I received by being an RA in the pre-AI age. I like to think the answer is yes because realignment by the RA is being driven not only through increased incentive to engage at a level comparable to a coauthor but also through the cost of producing said robustness checks and accessing pre-existing literature reducing.

Zoey Yu Zhao's avatar

The pipeline point is exactly what I’ve been thinking about. As an RA before AI, I knew where my contribution was: I did most of the production of professors’ ideas, and professors did the verification and judgment. Now, on some projects, it’s flipped. A lot of the first-pass results already exist by the time they reach me, and my job is to check them.

Honestly, it felt a bit strange at first. I couldn’t really see my own contribution anymore, and the AI-assisted results were often better than what I would have produced. It made me worry a little about whether I’ll be replaced by AI by the time I graduate. But it also pushed me to learn from what professors produced, to follow how they think through a problem, and to look for things they hadn’t thought of. When I catch something that hadn’t been considered and we talk it through before the final call, that’s when I feel I grow the most.

So maybe the pipeline isn’t broken, just flipped? I’m still not sure human capital gets passed down as well this way as it did when RAs did the production themselves.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?